• Shahid Javed Butt Department of Horticulture, PMAS-Arid Agriculture University, Rawalpindi, Pakistan
  • Servet Varis Namik Kemal University, faculty of agriculture, Tekirdag, Turkey
  • Zahoor Ahmad University of Haripure, Kayber Pakhtoonkha, Pakistan
  • Ali Raza Gurmani University of Haripure, Kayber Pakhtoonkha, Pakistan
  • Amjad Farooq Department of Horticulture, PMAS-Arid Agriculture University, Rawalpindi, Pakistan


The seeds and the subsequent transplants of important salad crop, lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.), were grown in different organic and inorganic soilless rooting media (hydroponic substrates), including soil-based and glasshouse border soil. The seedlings obtained from the seedling media (SM) performed differently with regard to seedling height and stem diameter, but remained non-significant for number of leaves of seedlings. Different planting media (PM) showed variable results from significant to non-significant with regard to physical parameters of the harvested crop. However, in most case, SM x PM interactions were proved to be non-significant, except plant height and weight of marketable outmost single leaf that were significant to SM and PM interaction. Over all, Perlite, peat compost, border soil and relatively straw bale, alone or in combination, were better when compared with soil-based compost and grapes marc. High tip burn was recorded, attributed to the relatively higher temperature of glasshouse near the stage of crop maturity.

Author Biographies

Shahid Javed Butt, Department of Horticulture, PMAS-Arid Agriculture University, Rawalpindi, Pakistan
Assistant Professor Department of Horticulture, PMAS-Arid Agriculture University, Rawalpindi, Pakistan
Servet Varis, Namik Kemal University, faculty of agriculture, Tekirdag, Turkey
Professor/Chairman, department of Horticulture
Zahoor Ahmad, University of Haripure, Kayber Pakhtoonkha, Pakistan
Assistant Professor, Soil and Environmental Sciences, Faculty of Agriculture
Ali Raza Gurmani, University of Haripure, Kayber Pakhtoonkha, Pakistan
Assistant Professor, Soil and Environmental Sciences, Faculty of Agriculture
Amjad Farooq, Department of Horticulture, PMAS-Arid Agriculture University, Rawalpindi, Pakistan
Assistant Professor, Department of Horticulture


Ahmed, C. M. S. and S. J. Butt. 1999. Effect of NPK on some yield components of tomato (Lycopersicon esculantum Mill.). ANADOLU Journal. pp 56-62.
Altintas, S. and S. Varis. 1992. Sera sebzelerinin saman balyalarında yetiştirilmeleri. HASAD. pp 36-38.
Bhat, N., M. Albaho, M. Suleiman, B. Thomas, P. George and S. I. Ali. 2013. Growing substrate composition influences growth, productivity and quality of organic vegetables. Asian Journal of Agricultural Sciences, pp 62-66.
Bilderback T. E., S. L. Warren, Jr. J. S. Owen and J. P. Albano. 2005. Healthy substrates need physicals too. Hort Technology. pp 747–751.
Bohme M., L. T. Hoang, and R.Vorwerk. 2001. Effect of different substrates and mineral as well as organic nutrition on the growth of cucumber in closed substrate systems. Acta Horticulturae. pp 165-172.
Bohme, M., J. Schevchenko, I.Pinker, and S. Herfort. 2008. Cucumber grown in sheep wool slabs treated with biostimulator compared to other organic and mineral substrates. Acta Horticulturae. pp 299-306.
Bunt, A. C. 1976. Modern Potting Composts. George Allen & Unwin Ltd London, pp 277.
Butt, S. J. and M. I. Al-Haq. 1993. Vegetable cultivation, a secret of manifold prosperities. Journal of Science Technology and Development. pp 46-51.
Butt, S. J. and S. Varis. 2000. Suitability of containerized rooting media by using bag culture technique for the quality production of crops grown under unheated glasshouse. Proceeding, 2nd International Symposium on New Technologies for Environmental Monitering and Agro-Application, Tekirdag Turkey. pp 179-186.
Cinkilic, H. 1997. Farklı besin kaynakları ve çozeltilerinin, perlit torba kültürüyle yetiştirilen marul ve domateste gelişme ve vemim üzerine etkisi. Doktora tezi, T.Ü.Tekirdag Ziraat Fakültesi, Bahçe Bitkileri Anabilim Dali. pp 212.
Fukuda, N., M. Yosinaka and K. Takayanagi. 1998. Effect of supplemental lighting during midnight to morning with light sources on the growth of lettuce and garland chrysanthemum. Science and Horticulture, 25th IHC, Brussels. pp 253.
Gruda, N. 2009. Do soilless culture systems have an influence on product quality of vegetables? Journal of Applied Botany and Food Quality. pp 141–147.
Gysi, C., F. Von-Allmen and R.U. Roeber. 1997. Lamb's lettuce in different growing media in closed recirculating soilless culture. Acta-Horticulturae Abst. pp 155-159.
Hartmann, H. T. and D. E. Kester. 1972. Plant propagation, principles and practices (2nd Ed.), Prantice-Hall Pvt. Ltd.
Herrera, F., J. E. Castillo, A. F. Chica and L. Lopez Bellido. 2008. Use of municipal solid waste compost (MSWC) as a growing medium in the nursery production of tomato plants. Bioresource Technology. pp 287-296.
Hong, G.L. and L. Shijun. 1996. Mechanism of optimal root-zone temperature relieving heat injury in shoot of lettuce. CAB Absts. pp 204.
Janick, J. 1979. Horticultural Review, Vol. II, AVI Pub. Co.Inc. pp 544.
Jones, L. and P. C. Beardsley. 1990. Home Hydroponics, and How to Grow it. Crown Pub. Inc N.Y. pp 141.
Kahraman, Ö. and A. Gül. 1998. Possibilities of using some soilless culture systems in the greenhouse lettuce production. Science and Horticulture, 25th IHC. pp 207.
Kratky, B. A. 1990. Design of a capillary, sub-irrigation hydroponic lettuce cultivation system for a remote area. Proc. Nat. Agr. Plastics Cong. pp 141-146.
Kratky, B. A., L. A. Peterson, M. Yamasaki and A. R. Krueger. 1994. Growing cucumbers in beverage cans resting in shallow tanks of aerated and non-aerated nutrient solution. Proc. Amer. Soc. for Plasticulture. pp 101-107.
Leoni, S., M. Cadinu, R. Gurudina, and B. Mededdu. 1988. Results from three tomato cultivation cycles in soilless culture in Mediterranean environment. Proc. 7th ISOSC. pp 265-276.
Martinez, P. F. and Y. M. M. Abdel Fattah. 1995. Effects of substrate warming in soilless culture on gerbera crop performance under seasonal variations. Acta Horticulturae. pp 31-40.
Mastouri, F., M. R. Hassandokht and Padasht M. N. Dehkaei. 2005. The effect of application of agricultural waste compost on growing media and greenhouse lettuce yield. Acta Horticulturae. pp 153–158.
Nelson, P. V. 1991. Greenhouse Operation and Management. Prentice Hall, N.J. pp 612.
Nissen, O. 1982. MSTAT Version 3.00/EM, Michigan State University, USA.
Olle, M. M. Ngouajio and A. Siomos. 2012. Vegetable quality and productivity as influenced by growing medium: a review. Žemdirbystė-Agriculture. pp 400-408.
Osmolovskaya, N. G. and L. N. Kuchaeva. 1998. Principles of ionic homeostasis in crop growth and quality regulation. Science and Horticulture, 25th IHC. pp 300.
Papadopoulos, A. P. 1994. Growing Greenhouse Seedless Cucumbers in Soil and Soilless Media. Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada Pub. No. 1902/E. pp 126.
Pollet, S., P. Bleyaert and R. Lemeur. 1998. Application of the Penman-Monteith model to calculate the transpiration of head lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) in glasshouse conditions. Science and Horticulture, 25th IHC. pp 110.
Rayder, J. E. 1979. Leafy Salad Vegetables. Avi Pub. Co. Inc, Connecicut. pp 226
Sakamoto, Y., S Watababe and K Okano. 1998. Physiology and morphology of tomato roots formed in the two hydroponic systems. Science and Horticulture, 25th IHC. pp 203.
San Bautista, A., R. Rueda, B. Pascual, J. V. Maroto and S. Lopez-Galarza. 2005. Influence of different substrates and nutrient solutions on the yields and the incidence of abiotic disorders of broccoli. Acta Horticulturae. pp 275-280.
Sawan, O. M., A. M. Eissa and A. F. Abou-Hadid. 1999. The effect of different growing media on cucumber seedling production, fruit yield and quality under greenhouse conditions. Acta Horticulturae. 369-376.
Saure, M. C. 2001. New views of the prerequisites for an occurrence of bitter pit in apple and its control by calcium sprays. International Symposium on Foliar Nutrition of Fruit Plants, Italy.
Schmidt, J. C., J. M. Gerber, and J. W. Courter. 1983. Hydroponics as a hobby, growing plants without soil, No. 844, Urbano, Illinois. pp 18.
Schmilewski, G. 2009. Growing medium constituents used in the EU. Acta Horticulturae. pp 3345.
Schwarz, M., 1975. Guide to Commercial Hydroponics. (3rd Ed.), Keter Pub. House Ltd. pp 136.
Åženiz, V. 1994. Seedling production in solanaceae crops. Acta Horticulturae. pp 243-250.
Serrano, L., R. Orozco, A. Martinez and O. Marfà. 1993. The use of fine graded perlites in bag culture ii. Yield and water consumption of lettuce. Acta Horticulturae. pp 435-442.
Sevgican, A. 1999a. Örtüaltı Sebzeciliği (Cilt-I). E.Ü. Ziraat Fakültesi Yayın No. 528, Bornova, Izmir, Türkiye.
Sevgican, A. 1999b. Örtüaltı Sebzeciliği (Cilt-II). E.Ü. Ziraat Fakültesi Yayın No. 526, Bornova, Izmir, Yürkiye.
Shibata, T., K. Iwao, and T. Takano. 1995. Effect of vertical air flowing on lettuce growing in a plant factory. Hort. Abst. pp 9686.
Varıs, S., S. Altintas and S. J. Butt. 2000. Topraksız tarım için en ucuz ortam ve yöntem: Cibre ve cibre torba kültürü. HASAD. pp 40-43.
Weerakkody, W. A. P., B. C. N. Peiris and K. P. S. B Premalal. 1998. Low cost, semi-intensive indoor structures for the yield stability and fruit quality of tomato under rainy weather and tropical conditions. Science and Horticulture, 25th IHC. pp 283.
Zhibin, Z, 1999. Update development of protected cultivation in Mainland China. Chronica Horticulturae. pp 11-15.